Lessons in Persuasion from a Fishing Guide

By Joey Asher

Category: Content, Practice

I drove to the Great Smokey Mountains near Townsend, TN recently to fly fish for trout. And I caught more than my fair share – 14 gorgeous rainbows. But who’s counting?

Spending time with my guide — a terrific, pony-tailed fisherman and author named Ian Rutter, of R&R Fly Fishing — I also learned a lot about persuasive communication.

Lesson 1: To Catch a Trout, Study the Trout

“Be a predator,” Ian said.

But that doesn’t mean thrashing the stream like a hungry bear.  Rather, Ian wanted me to study the trout’s habitat.  Learn where trout feed, what bugs they eat, and how those bugs flow through the water.  Then you can make an offer consistent with the trout’s environment.

The same is true about persuasive communication.  To persuade, you must study the audience’s habitat and fit your proposal into that environment.

Let’s say that you’re trying to win the business of an auto leasing company.  You can’t say, “We have a great firm and many big clients.”  You must study the world of auto leasing.  Are owners worried about negotiating deals with manufacturers?  Are they trying to reduce the terms of their leases?  Are they trying to improve relationships with insurance companies?

Figure out those things and then present an idea to address those problems.  Then you’ll maximize the chance of an owner taking your fly.

Lesson 2: To Catch a Trout, You Have to Listen to the Trout

Ian taught me that you must have a dialogue with the trout.  You must listen and adjust.  Last Friday, Mr. Trout said “no” several times before saying “yes.”

We started with a fly called a “Parachute Adams”, which floats like a bug on the surface.

Mr. Trout said, “No thanks.”

We switched to a floating “black ant” fly.  “Ants fall out of trees all day long,” Ian said. “This one usually kills them.”

But Mr. Trout said, “I’m not interested.”

Then we returned to the “Parachute Adams”.  But this time we added a “dropper fly”, tying an 18-inch line to the bend in the hook and attaching a “nymph”, which mimics an underwater bug.  Two flies on one rig!

Mr. Trout said, “Looks like dinner to me.”   We went on a tear.

The point is that we had a discussion with the trout and found a point of connection.

Similarly, great speakers know that persuasion happens more readily through dialogue.

Let’s say that you’re trying to persuade your partners to move into a new market.  You’ll increase your chances for success if, during your presentation, you take questions rather than trying to ram your ideas through with logic alone.  Let your partners object.  Then you can respond, adjust, and increase your chances of success.

Lesson 3: Trout Care About Your Presentation Style

“Nice cast Joey,” Ian said. “Now hold up the rod tip and let the fly drift as naturally as possible.”

Trout care how a fly is presented. They are most likely to bite if the presentation is authentic.

Similarly, speakers with an authentic style are more persuasive. We tend to believe people who sound like they’re speaking to a close friend.

Just a few lessons from a skilled Tennessee fly fisherman and some Smokey Mountain rainbows on how to hook and land a skeptical audience.

 © Wickedgood | Dreamstime.com – Rainbow Trout Isolated

Speechworks is a communication and selling skills coaching firm. We teach professionals how to craft and deliver complex messages in a simple, persuasive manner. Since 1986, through workshops and one-on-one instruction, we have helped countless individuals become better presenters and communicators. You can reach us at 404.266.0888, speech@speechworks.net or on the web at www.speechworks.net

Joey Asher

Joey is the President of Speechworks, a communication and selling skills coaching firm. He has worked with thousands of professionals, helping them learn to communicate in a way that connects with clients and audiences. He is also the author of four books on communication skills: “15 Minutes Including Q&A: a Plan to Save the World from Lousy Presentations,” “How to Win a Pitch: The Five Fundamentals That Will Distinguish You from the Competition,” “Selling and Communication Skills for Lawyers,” and “Even A Geek Can Speak.” He can be reached at 404-266-0888 or joey@speechworks.net.


Stop Scaring Yourself Off the Stage

Stop Scaring Yourself Off the Stage By Lauren Marlow Category: Nerves If you suffer from a fear of public speaking, you are not alone. Polls indicate that the fear of public speaking affects 70-75% [...]


How to Give a Great Webinar

CLICK HERE to listen/view the recorded webinar "How to Effectively Bookend Your Presentations" How to Give a Great Webinar By Joey Asher Category: Content Leo Tolstoy began his masterpiece “Anna Karenina” with the sentence “All [...]